Nonfiction Book Writing, Self Publishing, & Marketing Coach

Ten Ways to Give Writing Feedback to Boost Your Success


Writing a book? Website? Promotional Materials?

Want to up level your already quality writing?

Whatever we write, we need to share it with our peers or professionals for feedback before we present it to our paying audience.

Getting writing feedback offers many benefits. Even though you know your topic well, you may have some old writing sins lurking in your copy. While a bit scary, if you can put your ego aside, you’ll get valuable ideas from others to make your writing more clear and inspiring. You will learn how to identify your writing strengths and weaknesses, and you will develop your own writing style and voice.

Congrats on your site and your 180 blog posts. They are full of great information for professionals like me, and I really appreciate reading them! I’m working on so many projects at the same time my priority is to build my opt-in list, and create rapport, so my next step will be to use the connections I have on LI to send them my free report ( when it will be ready) and ask them their opinion and feedback. It is a sincere pleasure reading your comments!

Patricia Gozlan, Prosperity Coach Expert

You can exchange feedback with your peers via email or you can join a writing or book group such as the one I offer at LinkedIn, or get individual or group coaching. Remember, your writing must be easy to understand or it won’t get read or sell.

10 Parts to Give Feedback On

  1. Does the opening grab your attention? How? Is it clear? Is it engaging?
  2. What syntax needs editing? (grammar) Are tenses consistent?
  3. Does it use action verbs rather than linking (to be) verbs? Do the verbs advance the story and tighten the writing?
  4. Does your piece show, not tell? Do you use senses of sight, sound, emotions, and touch? Does it engage rather than tell? Do you use creative non-fiction techniques such as dialogue?
  5. Do you have redundancies that slow your writing down?
  6. Does your writing use adjectives and adverbs too much?
  7. Is it factually accurate?
  8. Is it coherent? Does it flow and sound natural? Is it easy to understand?
  9. Are the dialogues believable? Does it have enough dialogue? (think creative non-fiction).
  10. Does the ending sum up or compel your reader to want to keep reading or take action?

3 Rules of Giving the Oreo Cookie Method Feedback

Over 25 years as a book coach, I’ve used this Oreo Cookie Method. You’ll develop bravery and confidence if you use this wisely with a trusted writing coach or peers. And, you’ll get great writing results that help you sell later.

1. First, give one general statement of the copy’s strength and what grabbed you.

Include one positive before you launch into correction mode. In any writing feedback group, you want to encourage new writers and make it safe to expose their mistakes.

2. Second, give more specific feedback in parentheses next to the sentence error.

Or, give specific feedback on what to leave out and what to keep as “gold.” Or, anything else that will make the writing better. We all want this one to keep our writing readable. Only readable copy helps you get readers and sales later on.

3. Last, Conclude with a positive and encouragement.

If you want to strengthen your writing before your audience sees it, take some time to get some writing feedback. Pros and emerging writers need it. Do this before you get your final line edit. Now, make me smile and give me a comment!

Want ongoing free help? Commit to Judy’s LinkedIn book group

Serious and committed to move forward much faster to get your cash flow going? See Judy’s coaching packages

Remember, any journey is easier and faster with a partner. Choose the path that suits you.

Judy Cullins

Judy Cullins

Book Coach at
Judy Cullins, MA, is a book coach extraordinaire with 30 years of expertise.In her VIP packages, she offers entrepreneurs, leaders, and upper management shortcuts to complete their ebook and print book fast. She teaches the essential skills to self-publish and market your book and services online with powerful results.
Judy Cullins
Similar posts
  • 3 Ways Kids Can Teach Us About Content Writing & Delivery As an author or entrepreneur, how are you at connecting with your audience? Do you ever feel like your business writing is overly formal? Stilted? Drab? Do you fall into patterns, using the same words you’ve always used and that everyone else is using too? You’re not alone. So many people struggle to make their [...]
  • Think You Need an Expensive Ghostwriter? An Alternative May Be Right Under Your Nose Hiring a ghostwriter to help write your book can be challenging and also expensive–or it can be as simple as thinking outside the box. Scenario #1 You have the makings of a good nonfiction book. You’ve drafted your thoughts and even organized them into chapters. You have [...]
  • How to Become a Writer – Overcome the 5 Biggest Challenges Have you always wanted to start and finish writing a book? What’s the biggest obstacle preventing you from achieving your goal? Knowing your greatest challenge is the first step to becoming a productive writer because it empowers you to create a structured plan and make progress. To understand the most common reasons aspiring writers struggle [...]
  • New Rules for Successful Authors in 2016 March. It’s my birthday month. Time to eat wonderful sushi and other gourmet faire. My friend, Leva and I arrived at Pacific Coast Grill at 12:30PM. The sun out, our hostess sent us outside for a table with a great view of the ocean. We wanted our “regular” table outside on this cool day. They [...]
  • How to Use Keywords to Build a Better Book Most people associate keyword research with PPC programs and SEO. But really, this data provides a window to the desires and ailments of the online masses. It gives you one of the most comprehensive looks at what your audience wants. Google receives over 3.3 BILLION searches per day – you won’t find a larger sample [...]
  • Chris Pirkey

    Judy, you are a continual delight with each email you send out! Over time, I have received, and acted on, many of your free instructions while writing my just completed novel! I look forward to joining one or more of your LI groups in the near future. Whatever prosperity you are enjoying today from your writings, you richly deserve! We need more like you to light up our world (sigh)!

    Chris Pirkey
    Author of 'Ryland's Promise' (soon to be offered on Amazon)

Ready to Finish Your Book?

Ready to Market on Facebook?